The Environment Always Wins
When a skilled investor meets a poor investment environment, it is the environment that wins. The case for designing the system around the people, not just selecting the people.
There is a famous observation by Warren Buffett, that when a management team with a brilliant reputation meets a business with a poor one, it is the business’s reputation that survives. The implication is uncomfortable: individual talent, however impressive, is frequently overwhelmed by structural forces. The industry, the incentives, the economics — these things shape outcomes more than the people inside them.
The same logic applies to investment management. When a skilled investor meets a poor investment environment, it is the environment that wins.
This is not a popular idea. The investment industry is built around the cult of the individual — the brilliant analyst, the contrarian fund manager, the storied CIO. We spend enormous energy on talent selection: scrutinising track records, conducting rigorous interviews, building compensation structures to attract the best minds. A lot less time is spent designing the conditions in which those minds operate. This is, arguably, the wrong allocation.
Continue reading
Drop your email to read the rest of "The Environment Always Wins" and unlock the other gated articles.
By submitting your email, you agree to receive a one-time access code and occasional updates from Andy Evans about new articles. Unsubscribe anytime via the link in any email. Your address will not be shared, sold, or used for any other purpose. See the privacy policy at . Privacy policy.